Bondi and Bronte beaches will finally be free of shark nets, a move that reflects growing concerns about the nets’ effectiveness and their harm to marine life, potentially changing how Sydney manages its famous coastline.
Nets Deemed ‘Pointless’ by Critics
Critics have long argued that the nets, positioned approximately 300 metres offshore, are outdated and give swimmers a false sense of security.
Standing only six metres high in water, often 10 metres deep, they do little to prevent sharks from swimming over them. Furthermore, they frequently entangle non-target species, including dolphins and critically endangered grey nurse sharks, raising serious concerns about their environmental impact.
Council Favours Modern Shark Mitigation Technology
Instead of relying on nets, Waverley Council plans to focus on newer technologies to ensure swimmer safety. These include drones, SMART drumlines (which allow for the tagging and release of sharks), and tagged listening stations. This decision follows an analysis by Humane Society International (HSI) showing that Bondi Beach has experienced three summers without shark nets catching a single target shark.
Government Consultation Drives Change
The council’s vote directly responds to the NSW Government’s commitment to consult with local communities about shark mitigation strategies. The government has indicated its willingness to consider alternatives to shark nets, and Waverley Council’s submission will be a key part of this process. This shift in approach follows other recent changes, such as the earlier removal of nets to protect endangered sea turtles during their nesting season.
Community Education Key to Success
While acknowledging that shark nets provide a sense of comfort to some, experts stress the importance of educating the public about their limitations. The council and the NSW government aim to inform the community about more effective and environmentally friendly ways to mitigate shark risks.
Shark Expert Highlights Environmental Impact
Dr Leonardo Guida, a shark expert from the Australian Marine Conservation Society, expressed concerns about shark nets’ impact on endangered marine life, particularly grey nurse sharks and sea turtles. He praised Waverley Council for its decision and urged others to follow suit.
DPI Responds to Council Vote
The NSW Department of Primary Industries (DPI) has stated that while beachgoer safety remains its priority, it is committed to protecting marine life. The DPI highlighted the effectiveness of SMART drumlines in minimising the capture of non-target species and maximising the survival of all animals. It also acknowledged the importance of community feedback in shaping the future of shark mitigation programs.
Other councils across NSW are expected to vote on the use of shark nets in their areas in the coming weeks. The outcome of these votes and Waverley Council’s submission will likely play a significant role in determining the future of shark mitigation strategies in the state.
Published Date 18-December-2024
